A hundred and ten people, one sound

Last week, I went to hear the Fidelio Orchestra play Mahler’s Sixth Symphony at Milton Court, part of the Guildhall School of Music, conducted by Rafaelo Morales. A hundred and ten players filled the stage. For the best part of an hour and a half they made a sound that no recording quite captures: the march that opens the symphony, the cowbells, the hammer blows of the finale.

I came out moved, and something more than moved. I felt full of admiration. Every one of those players had spent years learning to do something very hard, and then had learnt to do it together, listening to each other, holding back and coming forward, so that a hundred and ten people became one sound. The holding back and coming forward was a very physical thing – watching the strings rising and falling in their seats as if on a thread pulled by the conductors bow (how many squats a day do you have to do to have that much strength in your knees and thighs?!!). People played with every fibre of their being, a total physical engagement as well as a mental one.

That is worth stopping on. The emotion I felt was only possible because they had the skill and the energy… and I could only feel it because, somewhere along the way, someone had taught me how to listen.

Skill and appreciation go together

We tend to talk about the arts as something to enjoy, and they are. But the enjoyment rests on two kinds of learning – someone has to learn to play, and someone has to learn to listen. Take away either and the evening in the concert hall does not happen.

Neither comes from nowhere. A violinist on that stage will have started as a child, with a teacher, an instrument and someone at home willing to pay for both. A listener who can follow a symphony for eighty minutes has usually been taken to concerts, or sung in a choir, or had a teacher who played them something and asked what they heard.

The Curriculum and Assessment Review last year found that music has the highest disadvantage attainment gap of any GCSE subject. That is not because poorer children are less musical – part of the reason, surely, is that acquiring the skill takes years, and years of lessons which cost money.

Who was on the stage

The orchestra spanned the generations, from players in their twenties to players in their eighties. That was a joy to see: a lifetime’s skill, being given away. Many of the younger players came from the Guildhall School of Music and Drama. Other older ones were amateurs, some of whom had been playing for fun all their lives but at least one of whom took it up in retirement and by hard work and practice is now skilled enough to play in an orchestra.

I wonder how many of the younger ones had been to state schools?

That is not a criticism of the players, who are superb, or of Guildhall. It is what the figures would lead you to expect. Richard Morrison noted in The Times in April that most conservatoire students are privately educated, although 93.7% of children are educated in the state sector. And the pipeline that feeds the conservatoires is narrowing:

The gap opens long before GCSE. As Bacon and O’Hanlon put it, “the arts entitlement gap starts in primary and has been travelling upwards.” The orchestra of 2040 is being chosen now, in primary schools, by whether a child ever gets the chance to begin.

Give children the chance, and watch what happens

At Cotswolds Arts Through Schools we see every week what happens when that chance is given. In Churchill Church last summer and in The Theatre, Chipping Norton this summer dozens of children sang their hearts out to audiences of schoolmates, parents and friends. This week at St Mary’s Church, Banbury, a hundred and fifty children from our schools sing under Caius Lee, Director of Music at Worcester College, Oxford, to an audience of 300 to 350. A lot of the children are singing in English as a second or third language. For most of the children it is the first time they have performed in a great building, to a full house, with a professional musician in front of them.

At The Sheldonian Theatre, Oxford, at Kids Go Classical, 150 children sang with a professional orchestra and Oxford Opera in Wren’s theatre, to 500 parents, friends and teachers who had paid to be there. They were accompanied by the Oxford Philharmonic and some singers from Oxford Opera. That evening the 150 children were part of one experience with 50 professional musicians and 500 listeners.

Weekly in African drumming and dance we see children with special educational needs, who at the first session are frightened by the noise and the movement. By the fifth week, every child had created a routine of their own and led the class in copying it. For them it was the first time in their lives they had led their peer group rather than followed. Their teachers told us the confidence created carried on through the rest of the week.

The pattern repeats in small schools across three counties. At Mickleton, staff said they had “never seen the children so calm and relaxed”. At Bledington, the school wrote that class sets of instruments, given “at a time of severe funding difficulties for schools”, were “invaluable”. Weekly singing teachers now work in some of our schools, and 40 class teachers have been trained to lead singing themselves.

None of these children is yet a Guildhall student. But every one of them has started – and one this autumn was performing with Oxford Opera’s chorus as a result of doing an opera workshop at school… and a small randomised trial in Málaga, published this year, points the same way: children given group music lessons grew in wellbeing, while those given nothing declined. Doing nothing is not neutral.

The orchestra starts in the primary school

When the final chord of Mahler’s Sixth had sounded, I thought of those children in Banbury and Oxford, and in the drumming circle. The players on that stage were once children who were handed an instrument and told they could. The question is who gets told.

A great orchestra is a hundred and ten people who were each given a chance and then given years of help as they gave years of their time and effort. We cannot give every child the years. But we can make sure that every child in a state primary school gets the first chance: to sing with others, to pick up a drum, to sit in a concert hall and feel what I felt. Some will become players. All of them can become listeners. Both matter.

Show children the vision, give them a chance, and they can have the ambition.